MSNBC Home
Newsvine Home
MSN Home
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
advertisement
advertisement

Did you cut back this holiday season?

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Ready To Join?

Results with 26 short comments
Total of 2,263 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

69.5%
Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget
1,573 votes
5.6%
No, I blew my budget
127 votes
20.2%
I spent about the same
458 votes
4.6%
Bah humbug! As usual
105 votes
Display Comments:
I spent about the same

I spent about $100 total on Christmas gifts in 2007, and spent less for 2008. I am spending ZERO from now own. Must fund retirement!

{"commentId":4697485,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"gregziglar"}
  • 1 vote
#1
 - Greg-281912
 - 8:28 am EST on Wed Jan 7, 2009
Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

I only bought for the kids and the one exchange gift on my husbands side. This was actually the best holiday season in years.

{"commentId":4698228,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"jujubug00"}
    #2
     - GoodbieGirl
     - 9:37 am EST on Wed Jan 7, 2009
    Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

    Stuck to a way smaller budget. I'm in NW and family in MW/South...didn't even see them. Oh well...will this summer.

    {"commentId":4700424,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"twisted"}
      #3
       - Xonenine
       - 11:47 am EST on Wed Jan 7, 2009
      Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

      We purchased $29 bicycles and helments for our three grandsons and two clothing outfits and earrings for our granddaughter. That's it!

      {"commentId":4701091,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"nmgrandma"}
      • 1 vote
      #4
       - nmgrandma
       - 12:23 pm EST on Wed Jan 7, 2009
      Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

      We spent very little this year. Instead adopted a kitten headed for the pound 2 days before Christmas. It was a perfect decision.

      {"commentId":4701263,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"lgroeschen"}
      • 3 votes
      #5
       - pj-362601
       - 12:32 pm EST on Wed Jan 7, 2009
      No, I blew my budget

      We are conservative in our spending all year and have always avoided carrying debt so we were able to take advantage great discounts!

      {"commentId":4703238,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"foxrun13"}
      • 1 vote
      #6
       - Bonnie-801911
       - 2:23 pm EST on Wed Jan 7, 2009
      Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

      We cut back to one exhange gift for each person and did the usual stocking stuffers. It was a great Christmas with less gifts!

      {"commentId":4703576,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"rvssznn"}
      • 2 votes
      #7
       - Suz-801938
       - 2:41 pm EST on Wed Jan 7, 2009
      Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

      I had made a pledge to make the holiday simpler. While I want to help our economy, I need to get make sure my car and home stay current.

      {"commentId":4704634,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"thankfultobeamomof3"}
      • 2 votes
      #8
       - thankfultobeamomof3
       - 3:37 pm EST on Wed Jan 7, 2009
      Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

      My "smaller budget" would seem austere to most Americans. I am proud of shedding the label "consumer" . "Austerity" has become my moniker

      {"commentId":4704778,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"smrtcookie04"}
      • 2 votes
      #9
       - smrtcookie04
       - 3:47 pm EST on Wed Jan 7, 2009
      Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

      We're going to continue using our dollars as votes. When some sanity is restored we'll spend again. (Which means never, I guess!)

      {"commentId":4705103,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"michaelarnold-contact"}
      • 1 vote
      #10
       - Mike G.-270496
       - 4:05 pm EST on Wed Jan 7, 2009
      Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

      I didn't have a choice... everyone says we need to spend to bring the economy back, but I have nothing to spend 8^P

      {"commentId":4706878,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"stephen12304"}
        #11
         - Steve Morgan
         - 5:59 pm EST on Wed Jan 7, 2009
        I spent about the same

        Instead of spending it on my family (who really don't need anything), we spent the amount on needy families in our community.

        {"commentId":4713015,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"finally08going"}
        • 1 vote
        #12
         - theonlyone-802787
         - 9:11 am EST on Thu Jan 8, 2009
        Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

        Sent emails and made calls to tell family and friends that I would not even send cards - donated to Salvation Army and pet rescues.

        {"commentId":4713790,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"gwenpac"}
        • 1 vote
        #13
         - Utahreb
         - 10:13 am EST on Thu Jan 8, 2009
        Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

        I bought items for the children in my family. I didn't get anything for the adults.

        {"commentId":4713856,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"mikkie23"}
          #14
           - American voter-22380
           - 10:17 am EST on Thu Jan 8, 2009
          Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

          no gifts this year, just a donation to plant trees in the rain fofest with various family member names.

          {"commentId":4714606,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"annckeirns"}
            #15
             - Ann Catherine Keirns
             - 11:05 am EST on Thu Jan 8, 2009
            Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

            I opted to treat my savings account with holiday cheer

            {"commentId":4715041,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"jheavey"}
              #16
               - Jim-548468
               - 11:31 am EST on Thu Jan 8, 2009
              Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

              easier to cut back now that my kids are older, more understanding of tight budgets

              {"commentId":4715307,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"donna-in-ship"}
                #17
                 - Missy-802969
                 - 11:47 am EST on Thu Jan 8, 2009
                Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

                I usually spend about $1200. This year I only spent $500-600.

                {"commentId":4715440,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"socal969"}
                  #18
                   - socal969
                   - 11:55 am EST on Thu Jan 8, 2009
                  Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

                  My husband was laid off throughout the holiday season so we had no choice but to cut back.

                  {"commentId":4716336,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"mayra-julian"}
                    #19
                     - Texan76
                     - 12:40 pm EST on Thu Jan 8, 2009
                    Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

                    My 'smaller budget' was <$50.00 compared to my usual $500.00. I work 2 jobs and week-to-week I am still falling behind.

                    {"commentId":4717046,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"scott-13"}
                      #20
                       - scott a d
                       - 1:14 pm EST on Thu Jan 8, 2009
                      I spent about the same

                      I refuse to play in to the media hype, and therefore contribute, to a recession. Christmas was the same as always .

                      {"commentId":4719399,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"unanicole"}
                        #21
                         - Nicole-803468
                         - 3:16 pm EST on Thu Jan 8, 2009
                        I spent about the same

                        I've fallen out of love w/ the commercialism of Christmas so I spent the same as last year - nothing - and added to my savings instead !

                        {"commentId":4845352,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"DivaCPA"}
                          #22
                           - Diva CPA TX
                           - 1:36 pm EST on Fri Jan 16, 2009
                          Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

                          I didn't buy any gifts.

                          {"commentId":4849364,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"lcgfrancis-1"}
                            #23
                             - Lia-457918
                             - 5:09 pm EST on Fri Jan 16, 2009
                            Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

                            I lost my Job and couldn;t afford any big gifts

                            {"commentId":4887229,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"hottexan75766"}
                              #24
                               - Tim Wood
                               - 5:29 pm EST on Mon Jan 19, 2009
                              Yes, I stuck to a smaller budget

                              cut everything

                              {"commentId":4897184,"threadId":"463110","contentId":"2281368","authorDomain":"slwei442"}
                                #25
                                 - AnvilofSteel
                                 - 11:36 am EST on Tue Jan 20, 2009