MSNBC Home
Newsvine Home
MSN Home
  • Conversation Tracker
  • Your Column
  • Replies
  • Friends
Type Comments Since You Last CheckedArticle Source Last Checked Stop Tracking All Clear Tracking All
advertisement

Should Barack Obama engage in direct talks with Iran as president?

advertisement
Ready To Join?

Newsvine is msnbc.com's social-news community where you can discuss stories, publish your own column, and connect with other news lovers.

Ready To Join?

Results with 323 short comments
Total of 37,421 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

86.5%
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute
32,373 votes
9.4%
No, unconditional talks with an enemy are dangerous
3,514 votes
4.1%
Not sure
1,534 votes
Display Comments:
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

YES! THE WORLD NEEDS TO SEE US AS WE USED TO BE

{"commentId":4039749,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"ABNAKI"}
  • 2 votes
#1
 - RICHARD S
 - 6:36 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

I always think that talking is better than fighting.

{"commentId":4039943,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"hasegawamaya"}
  • 3 votes
#2
 - Maya-442692
 - 6:50 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

Diplomacy does't mean unconditonal and talk is cheap and easy and allways works better than saber rattling

{"commentId":4040030,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"wsmcquainathm"}
  • 3 votes
#3
 - wsm
 - 6:56 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

Discussion should cover Afghanistan ,the Taliban and the shape of middle east peace which would include nuclear weapons control!

{"commentId":4040031,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"susanllpeterson"}
  • 2 votes
#4
 - Bruce House
 - 6:56 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

Yes, but use a strong experienced Senator first as an introduction to diplomacy.

{"commentId":4040069,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"kcxx2"}
  • 3 votes
#5
 - KCx2
 - 6:58 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

Communication is better than bombing. We've always got farther with talks then a jerk gets in office.

{"commentId":4040093,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"jibade7"}
  • 3 votes
#6
 - JoMan
 - 7:00 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

I think it would be appropriate to send his Sec. of State. We have to hear what the other side is saying.

{"commentId":4040255,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"eileenleft32"}
  • 2 votes
#7
 - Eileen Left
 - 7:11 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

He sould send top officials in first. He should not be part of the negotiations until iran is willing to work with us.

{"commentId":4040414,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"sf46aron"}
  • 3 votes
#8
 - sfa64
 - 7:22 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

We do not need another illegal war of choice like the Village Idiot began to outdo his daddy. No more wars!

{"commentId":4040465,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"Mmro"}
  • 4 votes
#9
 - Mmr.o-542939
 - 7:25 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

Does it ever hurt to at least talk?

{"commentId":4040841,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"catsanity"}
  • 3 votes
#10
 - Old Soul
 - 7:53 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

Keep in mind that he is a figurehead and up for election himself

{"commentId":4040862,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"wishowl"}
  • 2 votes
#11
 - Linda from AZ
 - 7:55 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

Secretary of State should carry the brief for President Obama to the Iranian president. But by all means, talk!

{"commentId":4040895,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"lorainel"}
  • 3 votes
#12
 - lorainel
 - 7:58 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

Absolutely. We really have no choice but to communicate.

{"commentId":4040918,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"chowloverwww"}
  • 4 votes
#13
 - CHOWLOVER
 - 8:00 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

Talking is necessary.

{"commentId":4041114,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"Slownomad"}
  • 2 votes
#14
 - Slownomad
 - 8:17 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

We need to give them 2 options: stop the nuc program or be bombed. Give them 2 weeks, then take proper action.

{"commentId":4041273,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"dadofcheese"}
    #15
     - dadofcheese
     - 8:31 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
    Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

    Yes, you can't resolve conflict by ignoring your foes.

    {"commentId":4041306,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"socalgal59"}
    • 1 vote
    #16
     - socalgal59
     - 8:33 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
    Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

    Not until he's president.

    {"commentId":4041319,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"TN0101"}
    • 1 vote
    #17
     - TN0101
     - 8:35 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
    Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

    What's wrong in talking? Iran will be forced to save face or be labeled as 'disagreeable'. Obama can really take advantage by this.

    {"commentId":4041402,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"bayravin"}
    • 2 votes
    #18
     - bayravin
     - 8:42 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
    Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

    We must at least TRY diplomacy!

    {"commentId":4041545,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"MaryAnne409207"}
    • 2 votes
    #19
     - MaryAnne-409207
     - 8:53 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
    No, unconditional talks with an enemy are dangerous

    Of course, he can do what he wants and the country will pay, all while he is clowned.

    {"commentId":4041882,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"basnetgl"}
    • 1 vote
    #20
     - Big Elephant
     - 9:23 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
    No, unconditional talks with an enemy are dangerous

    Diplomacy does not start at the top. It should happen at lower levels and then move up the food chain.

    {"commentId":4042139,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"vlc55"}
    • 1 vote
    #21
     - opine-550534
     - 9:45 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
    Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

    This is not a correct choice - "direct talks" does not mean "unconditional"!

    {"commentId":4042201,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"ppeoples"}
    • 1 vote
    #22
     - Middle class woman over 60
     - 9:51 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
    Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

    Military might only can not win, there must be diplomacy. Keep your friends close, but keep your enemies closer.

    {"commentId":4042268,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"Steve-NV"}
    • 3 votes
    #23
     - Steve- NV
     - 9:55 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
    Not sure

    It depends on the situation.

    {"commentId":4042485,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"ConcernedCali"}
    • 1 vote
    #24
     - ConcernedCali
     - 10:14 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008
    Yes, diplomacy is the best approach to resolving the dispute

    We shouldn't be afraid to come to the table and talk as well as listen to others, even those who don't like us. It might help matters.

    {"commentId":4042637,"threadId":"417392","contentId":"2105477","authorDomain":"jc-crazycat"}
    • 2 votes
    #25
     - jc_crazycat
     - 10:29 pm EST on Wed Nov 12, 2008